From the New York Times
Study Looks at Local Political News
By JACQUES STEINBERG
Published: February 14, 2005
n the month leading up to last year's presidential election, local television
stations in big cities devoted eight times as much air time to car crashes and
other accidents than to campaigns for the House of Representatives, state senate,
city hall and other local offices, according to a new study to be released tomorrow.
The study - which was carried out by researchers at the University of Wisconsin
and Seton Hall University in South Orange, N.J., and led by the Norman Lear
Center at the Annenberg School for Communication at the University of Southern
California - analyzed more than 4,000 local newscasts that were broadcast in
11 major markets, including New York, Los Angeles, Philadelphia and Miami, in
the four weeks before the election.
It found that 8 percent of those broadcasts included a report about a local
race. By contrast, more than half those broadcasts contained a report on the
presidential race.
The apparent disparity between local and national political coverage at the
local level is being added to the debate over how many television stations a
company may own. Last week, the researchers filed their report with the Federal
Communications Commission, which is in the midst of an inquiry into easing local
ownership rules.
The study will be formally presented tomorrow at a news conference hosted by
Senator John McCain of Arizona, a critic of efforts to ease restrictions on
media ownership.
"I think most stations fear that covering politics is ratings poison,"
said Martin Kaplan, associate dean of the Annenberg School and one of the lead
authors of the study. "Interestingly, they don't seem to fear that running
a torrent of political ads hurts them with their audience."
Mr. Kaplan, who hosts a weekly program on "Air America," a liberal
talk radio network, and his colleagues found that in the 11 markets studied,
the hours of advertising by House candidates eclipsed actual coverage of those
races by a ratio of 5 to 1.
Among the study's most jarring findings was in the Seattle market, where in
the month before the gubernatorial election, which would turn out to be razor
thin, 95 percent of the newscasts analyzed by the researchers had no reports
on the race.
"Time spent on teasers, bumpers and intro music in Seattle outnumbered
time covering the Washington gubernatorial race by 14 to 1," the researchers
wrote.
In an attempt to showcase stations that did focus on local politics, Mr. Kaplan
and his colleagues - Ken Goldstein, a professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison,
and Matthew Hale, an assistant professor at Seton Hall - cited WFAA, the ABC
affiliate in Dallas. The station devoted more than 15 percent of its campaign
coverage to local races, more than double the national average of 6 percent,
the researchers found.
"It's easier, quite frankly, to cover car wrecks, murders and spot news,"
said Cliff Williams, managing editor of WFAA. "It takes more time, it takes
more manpower, to do politics. But we believe our viewers expect that coverage."